Costs
Four things a business broker actually does, and where incentives stop matching yours
Business brokers explained: the four things an intermediary does, where their incentives stop matching yours, and the engagement clauses to read closely.
Most owners hire a broker for the wrong reason. They think they are buying access to buyers. What they are mostly buying is a process, and the difference matters, because a process is something you can judge before you sign, while access is something you can only judge afterwards.
This page is about what an intermediary actually does for a small-business sale, where their interests stop matching yours, and what to read carefully in the agreement before you sign it.
What to take away
- A broker is not your adversary, but the incentives are not identical, and knowing exactly where they diverge is more useful than assuming either loyalty or bad faith.
- Set expectations at the beginning about what you will be told and when.
The four things a broker does
Keeps the sale confidential. This is the least glamorous and often the most valuable service. Staff who learn the business is for sale start job-hunting. Customers who learn it start taking calls from competitors. Suppliers who learn it tighten terms. A broker markets a business as an anonymous profile, screens enquiries, and gets a confidentiality agreement signed before anything identifying is released. Doing this yourself, while also running the business, is where most owner-led sales come apart.
Filters the buyers. A public listing attracts curious competitors, people who cannot fund anything, and brokers hunting for their own clients. What those enquirers actually saw is described in how listings are written. Someone has to sort them. Qualification means establishing that a buyer has funds or a credible route to funds, has a reason to want this specific business, and is not simply collecting information. Every unqualified buyer you meet costs a week and a piece of your file.
Builds the file. A prepared information package (normalized earnings with the adjustments explained, a customer picture, the operating story, the reason for sale), is what lets a buyer form a view quickly. Weak packages produce low offers, because a buyer who cannot see the business clearly prices the uncertainty.
Runs a process rather than a conversation. This is the part with the largest effect on price. A single interested buyer negotiating alone sets the terms. Several buyers moving to a deadline change the seller's position entirely, without the seller having to bluff about anything. A broker's real bargaining power is competitive tension, and the ability to create it is the fair test of whether one is worth hiring.
Where the broker's interests stop matching yours
A broker is not your adversary, but the incentives are not identical, and knowing exactly where they diverge is more useful than assuming either loyalty or bad faith.
A completed deal beats a better deal. The broker is generally paid on completion. Your last increment of price is a small change to their fee and a large change to your outcome, and it is the increment most likely to break the deal. Near the end of a negotiation you will feel pressure to accept. Some of that pressure is the market. Some of it is the fee structure. You are the only person who can tell them apart, so decide your walk-away position while you are still calm.
Winning the listing beats an honest valuation. Owners hire the broker who says the highest number. Brokers know this. An opinion of value offered before anyone has examined your records is a marketing document, not an appraisal. Ask instead which adjustments they would make to your earnings and why, what they think a buyer will challenge, and what they would want fixed before going to market. Those answers tell you whether they have read your business. A number does not.
Their timeline is not your timeline. A broker carries several engagements. Attention flows to whichever is moving. A business that stalls gets less of it, which is one reason exclusivity periods deserve attention.
Some intermediaries represent buyers. Buy-side advisers, search funds and acquisition-minded companies all approach owners directly. Establish at the first meeting who any given person is paid by. It changes the meaning of everything they subsequently say.
Reading the engagement agreement
This is an engagement letter like any other professional appointment, and the same care applies.
Engagement agreement clauses to check
- Exclusivity and termrenewal or decision?
- Terminationnotice and amount owed
- Tail periodduration and buyers covered
- Buyer registerwritten list at termination
- Fee triggercompletion, offer, or LOI
- Considerationearn-outs, financing, property, consulting
- Deferred paymentfee timing on full amount
This is the document that decides how much control you keep. Read every clause below before signing; each is negotiable in principle, and each has caused avoidable arguments.
| Clause | What to establish |
|---|---|
| Exclusivity and term | How long is the broker the only channel, and what happens at expiry: automatic renewal, or a decision you have to make? |
| Termination | Can you exit before the term ends, on what notice, and what is owed if you do? |
| Tail (or trailing) period | After the engagement ends, for how long does the broker still earn a fee on a sale, and to whom does that apply? |
| Buyer register | Is the tail limited to a written list of buyers the broker actually introduced, delivered to you at termination? An unlimited tail can mean paying on a sale you found yourself. |
| Fee trigger | Is the fee earned on completion, on an accepted offer, or on a signed letter of intent? These are very different commitments. |
| What counts as consideration | Does the fee apply to earn-outs, seller financing, retained property, or consulting agreements: money you may never receive, or receive years later? |
| Payment timing on deferred amounts | If part of the price is deferred, is the fee payable at closing on the full headline figure, or as you are actually paid? |
| Retainers and expenses | What is payable regardless of outcome, and is it credited against the success fee? |
| Excluded parties | Can you carve out named buyers you were already talking to before the engagement? |
| Dual representation | Can the broker act for the buyer too, and what disclosure and consent applies if they do? |
The tail combined with a vague buyer register is the clause most likely to produce an unexpected bill long after you thought the relationship ended. Insist the register be a written list, delivered when the engagement ends.
Fees on deferred consideration decide whether you might owe a fee at closing on money that arrives over years or never arrives at all. That is a real risk when part of the price is an earn-out.
Questions worth asking before you appoint anyone
Questions worth asking
- How many businesses like mine have you taken to completion, not merely listed?
- Of your last several engagements, how many completed, and where did the others fail?
- Who does the workyou, or someone I have not met?
- How will you market this without identifying my business, and what does a buyer see before signing a confidentiality agreement?
- How do you qualify a buyer's ability to pay, and what evidence do you require?
- What in my accounts will a buyer's accountant question?
- Do you also act for buyers?
- Which parts of the process will you hand to my lawyer and accountant rather than handle yourself?
The last one matters more than it looks. A broker is not a lawyer and not an accountant. The contract, the tax position and the verification of earnings belong to people qualified to be liable for them. A broker who blurs those lines is a warning sign, not a bargain.
Questions before appointing a broker
- How many like mine completed, not listed?
- Last engagementshow many completed, where failed?
- Who does the workyou or unseen staff?
- How will you market without identifying my business?
- How do you qualify a buyer's ability to pay?
- What will a buyer's accountant question?
- Do you also act for buyers?
- Which parts go to my lawyer and accountant?
When a broker is not the answer
Sometimes the sensible answer is no intermediary, or a different one.
- You already have the buyer.Someone running a deliberate search may already have found you. If a competitor, a supplier, a partner or a manager is the obvious purchaser, you may need a lawyer and an accountant far more than a broker. What you lose is competitive tension; what you save is a fee on a buyer you found. Be honest about how firm that buyer really is before you decide, because a single unopposed buyer negotiates from a strong position.
- The business is not ready.Marketing a business with unreconciled accounts and undocumented processes wastes the one first impression you get with each buyer. Fix that first; see what to do in the year before a sale.
- The transaction is large or complex enough for a different kind of adviser.Multiple entities, several jurisdictions, institutional buyers, or a carve-out from a larger group are corporate finance work rather than main-street brokerage. The skills genuinely differ.
- You are not actually selling.Testing the market to discover a number has costs: confidentiality risk, staff anxiety, and a business that has been seen and passed over. If you want a number, commission a valuation. If you want to sell, run a process.
Judging the work once it starts
Set expectations at the beginning about what you will be told and when.
Diagnosing a stalled sale funnel
- No enquiries: marketing or pricing problem
- Enquiries, no signed agreements: positioning problem
- Meetings, no offers: internal business or price problem
- Consistent low offers: owner dependence, customer concentration, earnings durability
Ask for a regular report showing enquiries received, confidentiality agreements signed, information packages released, meetings held, and offers received.
The funnel shape reveals where a stalled process is stuck. No enquiries points to a marketing or pricing problem, while enquiries that never become signed agreements signal a positioning problem. Meetings that never turn into offers usually mean an internal business problem, or a price the market rejects.
That last case is worth confronting early. A well-run process that yields consistent, roughly similar offers well below your expectation signals something about the business: usually owner dependence, customer concentration, or earnings durability. The temptation is to change broker.
Instead, ask what every one of those buyers saw. You can return to market later, once you have fixed it. You cannot un-see a stale listing.
The short version
A good intermediary earns their fee by protecting confidentiality, filtering out buyers who were never going to complete, and presenting earnings a buyer can trust. They also create enough competition that you are not negotiating alone.
A license or brand guarantees none of that. Judge the person on process, not on the number they open with, and read the engagement letter as carefully as the sale contract.
Common questions
Can I negotiate the fee?
The base it is calculated on is usually more negotiable than the rate, and matters more. Ask what happens to the fee on deferred amounts you may never receive.
What if I want to end the engagement early?
Read the termination clause before you sign, and insist that any tail applies only to a written list of buyers actually introduced, handed to you when the engagement ends.
Should the broker be the one who values my business?
They can tell you what buyers have paid for businesses like yours. A figure offered before anyone has read your accounts is a pitch, and should be treated as one.
Do I still need an accountant and a lawyer if the broker is good?
Yes. A broker is neither, carries no liability for the numbers or the contract, and a good one will say so first.
In this guide
- Broker requirements collide in three directions: the law's, yours and theirsWhat the law requires of an intermediary, what you should require before signing an engagement, and what they will require of you, with where those collide.
- Business brokers: six engagement letter clauses to read before signingBusiness brokers' engagement letters taken apart: six clauses, how each follows the deal structure, who pays whom, and the costs no invoice ever shows.
- Business broker engagement patterns: six invented engagements and what each one teachesSix invented business broker engagement patterns, each shown as it appears, how it plays out, and what to study, with real rules and providers noted.
- Matching a business broker service to your deal, and what the fee coversMatch the kind of intermediary to your transaction, then test the individual on completions, process, references and liability before any price is quoted.
- Five intermediary arrangements in a small business sale, and whose interest each servesFive ways to arrange the intermediary in a small business sale, from exclusive broker engagements to a franchisor resale desk, and whose interest each serves.
